cookbook 'firewall', '= 2.5.1'
firewall
(98) Versions
2.5.1
-
-
6.3.9
-
6.3.8
-
6.3.7
-
6.3.6
-
6.3.5
-
6.3.4
-
6.3.3
-
6.3.2
-
6.3.1
-
6.3.0
-
6.2.18
-
6.2.17
-
6.2.16
-
6.2.15
-
6.2.14
-
6.2.13
-
6.2.12
-
6.2.11
-
6.2.10
-
6.2.9
-
6.2.8
-
6.2.7
-
6.2.6
-
6.2.5
-
6.2.4
-
6.2.3
-
6.2.2
-
6.2.1
-
6.2.0
-
6.1.0
-
6.0.2
-
6.0.1
-
6.0.0
-
5.1.0
-
5.0.0
-
4.0.3
-
4.0.2
-
4.0.1
-
4.0.0
-
3.0.2
-
3.0.1
-
3.0.0
-
2.7.1
-
2.7.0
-
2.6.5
-
2.6.4
-
2.6.3
-
2.6.2
-
2.6.1
-
2.6.0
-
2.5.4
-
2.5.3
-
2.5.2
-
2.5.1
-
2.5.0
-
2.4.0
-
2.3.1
-
2.3.0
-
2.2.0
-
2.1.0
-
2.0.5
-
2.0.4
-
2.0.3
-
2.0.2
-
2.0.1
-
2.0.0
-
1.6.2
-
1.6.1
-
1.6.0
-
1.5.2
-
1.5.1
-
1.5.0
-
1.4.0
-
1.3.0
-
1.2.0
-
1.1.2
-
1.1.1
-
1.1.0
-
1.0.2
-
1.0.1
-
1.0.0
-
0.11.8
-
0.11.6
-
0.11.4
-
0.11.2
-
0.11.0
-
0.10.2
-
0.10.0
-
0.9.2
-
0.9.0
-
0.8.2
-
0.8.0
-
0.6.0
-
0.5.7
-
0.5.6
-
0.5.5
-
0.5.2
-
0.5.0
Follow114
- 6.3.9
- 6.3.8
- 6.3.7
- 6.3.6
- 6.3.5
- 6.3.4
- 6.3.3
- 6.3.2
- 6.3.1
- 6.3.0
- 6.2.18
- 6.2.17
- 6.2.16
- 6.2.15
- 6.2.14
- 6.2.13
- 6.2.12
- 6.2.11
- 6.2.10
- 6.2.9
- 6.2.8
- 6.2.7
- 6.2.6
- 6.2.5
- 6.2.4
- 6.2.3
- 6.2.2
- 6.2.1
- 6.2.0
- 6.1.0
- 6.0.2
- 6.0.1
- 6.0.0
- 5.1.0
- 5.0.0
- 4.0.3
- 4.0.2
- 4.0.1
- 4.0.0
- 3.0.2
- 3.0.1
- 3.0.0
- 2.7.1
- 2.7.0
- 2.6.5
- 2.6.4
- 2.6.3
- 2.6.2
- 2.6.1
- 2.6.0
- 2.5.4
- 2.5.3
- 2.5.2
- 2.5.1
- 2.5.0
- 2.4.0
- 2.3.1
- 2.3.0
- 2.2.0
- 2.1.0
- 2.0.5
- 2.0.4
- 2.0.3
- 2.0.2
- 2.0.1
- 2.0.0
- 1.6.2
- 1.6.1
- 1.6.0
- 1.5.2
- 1.5.1
- 1.5.0
- 1.4.0
- 1.3.0
- 1.2.0
- 1.1.2
- 1.1.1
- 1.1.0
- 1.0.2
- 1.0.1
- 1.0.0
- 0.11.8
- 0.11.6
- 0.11.4
- 0.11.2
- 0.11.0
- 0.10.2
- 0.10.0
- 0.9.2
- 0.9.0
- 0.8.2
- 0.8.0
- 0.6.0
- 0.5.7
- 0.5.6
- 0.5.5
- 0.5.2
- 0.5.0
Provides a set of primitives for managing firewalls and associated rules.
cookbook 'firewall', '= 2.5.1', :supermarket
knife supermarket install firewall
knife supermarket download firewall
firewall Cookbook
Provides a set of primitives for managing firewalls and associated rules.
PLEASE NOTE - The resource/providers in this cookbook are under heavy development. An attempt is being made to keep the resource simple/stupid by starting with less sophisticated firewall implementations first and refactor/vet the resource definition with each successive provider.
Requirements
Chef 12.4.x+ is required. We are currently testing against 12.5.1. If you need Chef 11 support, please try pinning back to a version less than 2.0, e.g.:
depends 'firewall', '< 2.0'
Supported firewalls and platforms
- UFW - Ubuntu, Debian
- IPTables - Red Hat & CentOS, Ubuntu
- FirewallD - Red Hat & CentOS >= 7.0 (IPv4 only support, needs contributions/testing)
- Windows Advanced Firewall - 2012 R2
Tested on:
* Ubuntu 12.04 & 14.04 with iptables, ufw
* Debian 7.8, 8.1 with ufw
* CentOS 5.11, 6.7 with iptables
* CentOS 7.1 with firewalld
* Windows Server 2012r2 with Windows Advanced Firewall
By default, Ubuntu chooses ufw. To switch to iptables, set this in an attribute file:
default['firewall']['ubuntu_iptables'] = true
By default, Red Hat & CentOS >= 7.0 chooses firewalld. To switch to iptables, set this in an attribute file:
default['firewall']['redhat7_iptables'] = true
Considerations that apply to all firewall providers and resources
This cookbook comes with two resources, firewall and firewall rule. The typical usage scenario is as follows:
run the
:install
action on thefirewall
resource named 'default', which installs appropriate packages and configures services to start on boot and starts themrun the
:create
action on everyfirewall_rule
resource, which adds to the list of rules that should be configured on the firewall.firewall_rule
then automatically sends a delayed notification to thefirewall['default']
resource to run the:restart
action.run the delayed notification with action
:restart
on thefirewall
resource. if any rules are different than the last run, the provider will update the current state of the firewall rules to match the expected rules.
There is a fundamental mismatch between the idea of a chef action and the action that should be taken on a firewall rule. For this reason, the chef action for a firewall_rule may be :nothing
(the rule should not be present in the firewall) or :create
(the rule should be present in the firewall), but the action taken on a packet in a firewall (DROP
, ACCEPT
, etc) is denoted as a command
parameter on the firewall_rule
resource.
iptables considerations
If you need to use a table other than *filter
, the best way to do so is like so:
node.default['firewall']['iptables']['defaults'][:ruleset] = {
'*filter' => 1,
':INPUT DROP' => 2,
':FORWARD DROP' => 3,
':OUTPUT ACCEPT' => 4,
'COMMIT_FILTER' => 100,
'*nat' => 101,
':PREROUTING DROP' => 102,
':POSTROUTING DROP' => 103,
':OUTPUT ACCEPT' => 104,
'COMMIT_NAT' => 200
}
Then it's trivial to add additional rules to the *nat
table using the raw parameter:
firewall_rule "postroute" do
raw "-A POSTROUTING -o eth1 -p tcp -d 172.28.128.21 -j SNAT --to-source 172.28.128.6"
position 150
end
Note that any line starting with COMMIT
will become just COMMIT
, as hash
keys must be unique but we need multiple commit lines.
Recipes
default
The default recipe creates a firewall resource with action install, and if node['firewall']['allow_ssh']
, opens port 22 from the world.
Attributes
-
default['firewall']['allow_ssh'] = false
, set true to open port 22 for SSH when the default recipe runs -
default['firewall']['allow_mosh'] = false
, set to true to open UDP ports 60000 - 61000 for Mosh when the default recipe runs default['firewall']['allow_winrm'] = false
, set true to open port 5989 for WinRM when the default recipe runsdefault['firewall']['ubuntu_iptables'] = false
, set to true to use iptables on Ubuntu / Debian when using the default recipedefault['firewall']['redhat7_iptables'] = false
, set to true to use iptables on Red Hat / CentOS 7 when using the default recipedefault['firewall']['ufw']['defaults']
hash for template/etc/default/ufw
default['firewall']['iptables']['defaults']
hash for default policies for 'filter' table's chains`default['firewall']['allow_established'] = true
, set to false if you don't want a related/established default rule on iptablesdefault['firewall']['ipv6_enabled'] = true
, set to false if you don't want IPv6 related/established default rule on iptables (this enables ICMPv6, which is required for much of IPv6 communication)default['firewall']['firewalld']['permanent'] = false
, set to true if you want firewalld rules to be added with--permanent
so they survive a reboot. This will be changed totrue
by default in a future major version release.
Resources
firewall
NB: The name 'default' of this resource is important as it is used for firewall_rule providers to locate the firewall resource. If you change it, you must also supply the same value to any firewall_rule resources using the firewall_name
parameter.
Actions
-
:install
(default action): Install and Enable the firewall. This will ensure the appropriate packages are installed and that any services have been started. -
:disable
: Disable the firewall. Drop any rules and put the node in an unprotected state. Flush all current rules. Also erase any internal state used to detect when rules should be applied. -
:flush
: Flush all current rules. Also erase any internal state used to detect when rules should be applied. -
:save
: Ensure all rules are added permanently under firewalld using--permanent
. Not supported on ufw, iptables. You must notify this action at the end of the chef run if you want permanent firewalld rules (they are not persistent by default).
Parameters
-
disabled
(default tofalse
): If set to true, all actions will no-op on this resource. This is a way to prevent included cookbooks from configuring a firewall. -
ipv6_enabled
(default totrue
): If set to false, firewall will not perform any ipv6 related work. Currently only supported in iptables. -
log_level
: UFW only. Level of verbosity the firewall should log at. valid values are: :low, :medium, :high, :full. default is :low. -
rules
: This is used internally for firewall_rule resources to append their rules. You should NOT touch this value unless you plan to supply an entire firewall ruleset at once, and skip using firewall_rule resources. -
disabled_zone
(firewalld only): The zone to set on firewalld when the firewall should be disabled. Can be any string in symbol form, e.g. :public, :drop, etc. Defaults to:public.
-
enabled_zone
(firewalld only): The zone to set on firewalld when the firewall should be enabled. Can be any string in symbol form, e.g. :public, :drop, etc. Defaults to:drop.
Examples
# all defaults firewall 'default' # enable platform default firewall firewall 'default' do action :install end # increase logging past default of 'low' firewall 'default' do log_level :high action :install end
firewall_rule
Actions
-
:create
(default action): If a firewall_rule runs this action, the rule will be recorded in a chef resource's internal state, and applied when providers automatically notify the firewall resource with action:reload
. The notification happens automatically.
Parameters
firewall_name
: the matching firewall resource that this rule applies to. Default value:default
raw
: Used to pass an entire rule as a string, omitting all other parameters. This line will be directly loaded byiptables-restore
, fed directly intoufw
on the command line, or run usingfirewall-cmd
.description
(default: same as rule name): Used to provide a comment that will be included when adding the firewall rule.position
(default: 50): relative position to insert rule at. Position may be any integer between 0 < n < 100 (exclusive), and more than one rule may specify the same position.-
command
: What action to take on a particular packet-
:allow
(default action): the rule should allow matching packets -
:deny
: the rule should deny matching packets -
:reject
: the rule should reject matching packets -
:masqerade
: Masquerade the matching packets -
:redirect
: Redirect the matching packets -
:log
: Configure logging
-
stateful
: a symbol or array of symbols, such as `[:related, :established]
that will be passed to the state module in iptables or firewalld.protocol
::tcp
(default),:udp
,:icmp
,:none
or protocol number. Using protocol numbers is not supported using the ufw provider (default for debian/ubuntu systems).direction
: For ufw, direction of the rule. valid values are::in
(default),:out
,:pre
,:post
.source
(Default is0.0.0.0/0
orAnywhere
): source ip address or subnet to filter.source_port
(Default is nil): source port for filtering packets.destination
: ip address or subnet to filter on packet destination, must be a valid IPport
ordest_port
: target port number (ie. 22 to allow inbound SSH), or an array of incoming port numbers (ie. [80,443] to allow inbound HTTP & HTTPS).
NOTE: protocol
attribute is required with multiple ports, or a range of incoming port numbers (ie. 60000..61000 to allow inbound mobile-shell. NOTE: protocol
, or an attribute is required with a range of ports.
interface
: (source) interface to apply rule (ie.eth0
).dest_interface
: interface where packets may be destined to goredirect_port
: redirected port for rules with command:redirect
logging
: may be added to enable logging for a particular rule. valid values are::connections
,:packets
. In the ufw provider,:connections
logs new connections while:packets
logs all packets.
Examples
# open standard ssh port firewall_rule 'ssh' do port 22 command :allow end # open standard http port to tcp traffic only; insert as first rule firewall_rule 'http' do port 80 protocol :tcp position 1 command :allow end # restrict port 13579 to 10.0.111.0/24 on eth0 firewall_rule 'myapplication' do port 13579 source '10.0.111.0/24' direction :in interface 'eth0' command :allow end # specify a protocol number (supported on centos/redhat) firewall_rule 'vrrp' do protocol 112 command :allow end # use the iptables provider to specify protocol number on debian/ubuntu firewall_rule 'vrrp' do provider Chef::Provider::FirewallRuleIptables protocol 112 command :allow end # can use :raw command with UFW provider for VRRP firewall_rule "VRRP" do command :allow raw "allow to 224.0.0.18" end # open UDP ports 60000..61000 for mobile shell (mosh.mit.edu), note # that the protocol attribute is required when using port_range firewall_rule 'mosh' do protocol :udp port 60000..61000 command :allow end # open multiple ports for http/https, note that the protocol # attribute is required when using ports firewall_rule 'http/https' do protocol :tcp port [80, 443] command :allow end firewall 'default' do enabled false action :nothing end
Providers
- See
libraries/z_provider_mapping.rb
for a full list of providers for each platform and version.
Different providers will determine the current state of the rules differently -- parsing the output of a command, maintaining the state in a file, or some other way. If the firewall is adjusted from outside of chef (non-idempotent), it's possible that chef may be caught unaware of the current state of the firewall. The best workaround is to add a :flush
action to the firewall resource as early as possible in the chef run, if you plan to modify the firewall state outside of chef.
Troubleshooting
To figure out what the position values are for current rules, print the hash that contains the weights:
require pp
default_firewall = resources(:firewall, 'default')
pp default_firewall.rules
Development
This section details "quick development" steps. For a detailed explanation, see [[Contributing.md]].
-
Clone this repository from GitHub:
$ git clone git@github.com:chef-cookbooks/firewall.git
-
Create a git branch
$ git checkout -b my_bug_fix
-
Install dependencies:
$ bundle install
Make your changes/patches/fixes, committing appropiately
Write tests
-
Run the tests:
bundle exec foodcritic -f any .
bundle exec rspec
bundle exec rubocop
bundle exec kitchen test
In detail:
- Foodcritic will catch any Chef-specific style errors
- RSpec will run the unit tests
- Rubocop will check for Ruby-specific style errors
- Test Kitchen will run and converge the recipes
License & Authors
- Author:: Seth Chisamore (schisamo@opscode.com)
- Author:: Ronald Doorn (rdoorn@schubergphilis.com)
- Author:: Martin Smith (martin@mbs3.org)
- Author:: Sander van Harmelen (svanharmelen@schubergphilis.com)
Copyright:: 2011-2015, Chef Software, Inc Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License"); you may not use this file except in compliance with the License. You may obtain a copy of the License at http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0 Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied. See the License for the specific language governing permissions and limitations under the License.
firewall Cookbook CHANGELOG
This file is used to list changes made in each version of the firewall cookbook.
v2.5.1 (2016-05-31)
- Protocol guard incorrectly prevents "none" protocol type on UFW helper (#128)
- Fix wrongly ordered conditional for converting ports to strings using port_to_s
- Fix notify_firewall attribute crashing firewall_rule provider (#130)
- Add warning if firewall rule opens all traffic (#132)
- Add ipv6 attribute respect to Ubuntu iptables (#138)
v2.5.0 (2016-03-08)
- Don't modify parameter for port (#120)
- Remove a reference to the wrong variable name under windows (#123)
- Add support for mobile shell default firewall rule (#121)
- New rubocop rules and style fixes
- Correct a README.md example for
action :allow
v2.4.0 (2016-01-28)
- Expose default iptables ruleset so that raw rules can be used in conjunction with rulesets for other tables (#101).
v2.3.1 (2016-01-08)
- Add raw rule support to the ufw firewall provider (#113).
v2.3.0 (2015-12-23)
Refactor logic so that firewall rules don't add a string rule to the firewall
when their actions run. Just run the action once on the firewall itself. This is
designed to prevent partial application of rules (#106)Switch to "enabled" (positive logic) instead of "disabled" (negative logic) on
the firewall resource. It was difficult to reason with "disabled false" for some
complicated recipes using firewall downstream.disabled
is now deprecated.Add proper Windows testing and serverspec tests back into this cookbook.
Fix the
port_to_s
function so it also works for Windows (#111)Fix typo checking action instead of command in iptables helper (#112)
Remove testing ranges of ports on CentOS 5.x, as it's broken there.
v2.2.0 (2015-11-02)
Added permanent as default option for RHEL 7 based systems using firewall-cmd.
This defaults to turned off, but it will be enabled by default on the next major version bump.
v2.1.0 (2015-10-15)
Minor feature release.
* Ensure ICMPv6 is open when ['firewall']['allow_established']
is set to true (the default). ICMPv6 is critical for most IPv6 operations.
v2.0.5 (2015-10-05)
Minor bugfix release.
* Ensure provider filtering always yields 1 and only 1 provider, #97 & #98
* Documentation update #96
v2.0.4 (2015-09-23)
Minor bugfix release.
* Allow override of filter chain policies, #94
* Fix foodcrtitic and chefspec errors
v2.0.3 (2015-09-14)
Minor bugfix release.
* Fix wrong conditional for firewalld ports, #93
* Fix ipv6 command logic under iptables, #91
v2.0.2 (2015-09-08)
- Release with working CI, Chefspec matchers.
v2.0.1 (2015-09-01)
- Add default related/established rule for iptables
v2.0.0 (2015-08-31)
- #84, major rewrite:
- Allow relative positioning of rules
- Use delayed notifications to create one firewall ruleset instead of incremental changes
- Remove poise dependency
- #82 - Introduce Windows firewall support and test-kitchen platform.
- #73 - Add the option to disable ipv6 commands on iptables
- #78 - Use Chef-12 style
provides
to address provider mapping issues - Rubocop and foodcritic cleanup
v1.6.1 (2015-07-24)
- #80 - Remove an extra space in port range
v1.6.0 (2015-07-15)
- #68 - Install firewalld when it does not exist
- #72 - Fix symbol that was a string, breaking comparisons
v1.5.2 (2015-07-15)
- #75 - Use correct service in iptables save action, Add serverspec tests for iptables suite
v1.5.1 (2015-07-13)
- #74 - add :save matcher for Chefspec
v1.5.0 (2015-07-06)
- #70 - Add chef service resource to ensure firewall-related services are enabled/disabled
- - Add testing and support for iptables on ubuntu in iptables provider
v1.4.0 (2015-06-30)
- #69 - Support for CentOS/RHEL 5.x
v1.3.0 (2015-06-09)
- #63 - Add support for protocol numbers
v1.2.0 (2015-05-28)
- #64 - Support the newer version of poise
v1.1.2 (2015-05-19)
- #60 - Always add /32 or /128 to ipv4 or ipv6 addresses, respectively.
- Make comment quoting optional; iptables on Ubuntu strips quotes on strings without any spaces
v1.1.1 (2015-05-11)
- #57 - Suppress warning: already initialized constant XXX while Chefspec
v1.1.0 (2015-04-27)
- #56 - Better ipv6 support for firewalld and iptables
- #54 - Document raw parameter
v1.0.2 (2015-04-03)
- #52 - Typo in :masquerade action name
v1.0.1 (2015-03-28)
- #49 - Fix position attribute of firewall_rule providers to be correctly used as a string in commands
v1.0.0 (2015-03-25)
- Major upgrade and rewrite as HWRP using poise
- Adds support for iptables and firewalld
- Modernize tests and other files
- Fix many bugs from ufw defaults to multiport suppot
v0.11.8 (2014-05-20)
- Corrects issue where on a secondary converge would not distinguish between inbound and outbound rules
v0.11.6 (2014-02-28)
[COOK-4385] - UFW provider is broken
v0.11.4 (2014-02-25)
[COOK-4140] Only notify when a rule is actually added
v0.11.2
Bug
- COOK-3615 - Install required UFW package on Debian
v0.11.0
Improvement
- [COOK-2932]: ufw providers work on debian but cannot be used
v0.10.2
- [COOK-2250] - improve readme
v0.10.0
- [COOK-1234] - allow multiple ports per rule
v0.9.2
- [COOK-1615] - Firewall example docs have incorrect direction syntax
v0.9.0
The default action for firewall LWRP is now :enable, the default action for firewall_rule LWRP is now :reject. This is in line with a "default deny" policy.
- [COOK-1429] - resolve foodcritic warnings
v0.8.0
- refactor all resources and providers into LWRPs
- removed :reset action from firewall resource (couldn't find a good way to make it idempotent)
- removed :logging action from firewall resource...just set desired level via the log_level attribute
v0.6.0
- [COOK-725] Firewall cookbook firewall_rule LWRP needs to support logging attribute.
- Firewall cookbook firewall LWRP needs to support :logging
v0.5.7
- [COOK-696] Firewall cookbook firewall_rule LWRP needs to support interface
- [COOK-697] Firewall cookbook firewall_rule LWRP needs to support the direction for the rules
v0.5.6
- [COOK-695] Firewall cookbook firewall_rule LWRP needs to support destination port
v0.5.5
- [COOK-709] fixed :nothing action for the 'firewall_rule' resource.
v0.5.4
- [COOK-694] added :reject action to the 'firewall_rule' resource.
v0.5.3
- [COOK-698] added :reset action to the 'firewall' resource.
v0.5.2
- Add missing 'requires' statements. fixes 'NameError: uninitialized constant' error. thanks to Ernad Husremović for the fix.
v0.5.0
- [COOK-686] create firewall and firewall_rule resources
- [COOK-687] create UFW providers for all resources
Foodcritic Metric
2.5.1 failed this metric
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:1
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:6
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:8
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:9
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:10
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:1
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:6
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:8
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:9
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:10
2.5.1 failed this metric
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:6
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:8
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:9
FC001: Use strings in preference to symbols to access node attributes: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:10
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:1
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:6
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:8
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:9
FC019: Access node attributes in a consistent manner: /tmp/cook/96462da7f3d92bf99e99ebee/firewall/attributes/iptables.rb:10